I, like many of you, have been captivated by drawings that have at least two different images imbedded within them. What do you see first? What does your answer reveal about your outlook? I have been meditating on these questions in light of the Roseanne tweet storm and the Samantha Bee outburst aimed at Ivanka Trump.
It seems that immediately lines were drawn in our country along two sides of each disturbing incident. People and companies rushed to respond based on what they saw and consequently what they thought they understood. Condemnation and defense, polar opposite reactions that said much about the people themselves. Each side sought to confirm their world view through Bee and Barr. Too often, people only see what they expect or even want to see.
In this week’s Torah portion, Sh’lach-Lecha, from the Book of Numbers, we experience the exact same dilemma. Moses sends out 12 spies to do reconnaissance of the Land of Israel. God commands Moses to choose the head of each tribe for this mission. It does not turn out well for our ancestors. The spies enter the land and only see giants. They are rightfully scared. The land seems completely inhospitable. Ten of the spies come back to the camp completely dismayed. Their worst fears are confirmed. They tell their fellow Israelites what they saw and how they felt. “We cannot possibly enter this horrible place,” they complain. “It is filled with giants. It is a place where the land devours its people.”
The people are whipped up into such a panic by this report that they naturally ignore the other two spies, Caleb and Joshua, who enter the camp carrying an enormous bunch of grapes. The cluster is so large that it requires the two of them to deliver them to the people. But, the Israelites are so upset, angry, and scared that they cannot even see the goodness that these grapes represent, nor can they hear the words shared by Caleb and Joshua that paint a completely opposite picture of their plight.
They do not dispute what the others saw, only the conclusion, the judgement they reached. Yes, the people are fierce and the land challenging, but God is with us and we will be successful. Just look at the goodness of these enormous grapes, they say.
Tragically, the people only saw what they were predisposed to see. They could not fathom the message of Caleb and Joshua. It ran so contrary to their primary response.
Our society, if it is to heal, grow and thrive, must break out of this pattern. We must be able to truly open our eyes to all possibilities, not just the one we expect. Social media makes it so difficult to even take a breath. Algorithms only fortify our point of view, making it even harder to see beyond what we are wired to see.
The children of Israel were banished from entering the Promised Land. That generation, so ossified in their perspective, had to die off so that a new generation could move ahead with a more open outlook. It took forty years. We do not have to wander quite so long. Take a breath, consider other possibilities before concluding, read perspectives that challenge you.
- Shabbat Vayigash - December 11, 2018
- Shabbat Toldot - November 7, 2018
- Temple Jeremiah Community Update – Oct. 31, 2018 - November 1, 2018
- A Letter to Our Congregation Following the Tragedy in Pittsburg - October 31, 2018
- Shabbat Chol Hamoed Sukkot - September 26, 2018
- Shabbat Ki Tetzei - August 22, 2018
- Shabbat Devarim - July 18, 2018
- Shabbat Sh’lach - June 4, 2018
- Shabbat Behar - May 2, 2018
- Shabbat Vayikra - March 13, 2018